Skip to content
GAMSATready

GAMSAT Section 2 quote prompts: Order

1 GAMSAT-style prompt on order. Each gives you five comments that disagree, so your job is to find the tension and argue a clear position. Give yourself about 30 minutes per essay.

Task A · ArgumentPrompt 1 of 1

Consider the following comments on order.

  • Order is the silence in which the powerful are most comfortable.

  • Better a hundred years of tyranny than one day of chaos.

    Proverb

  • Every settled order was once somebody's disruption that happened to win.

  • We crave order until it is enforced against us, then we call it oppression.

  • Stability can be the achievement of a just society or the symptom of an exhausted one.

Write a piece in response to one or more of these comments. Your essay will be assessed on the quality of your argument and the way you express it.

A way into this prompt

A defensible thesis is that order is a precondition for almost every human good and also the favourite disguise of injustice, which is why the demand to keep the peace deserves both gratitude and suspicion. Open by honouring its necessity, that without predictable rules and basic security there is no medicine, no contract, no freedom worth the name, only the rule of the strongest. Then complicate it: order is never neutral about who it serves, and calls to preserve stability often mean preserving a particular distribution of power that suits whoever is already on top. A strong third move distinguishes an order that protects everyone's ability to live and dissent from one that simply suppresses the friction of the discontented. Caution: resist both the authoritarian reflex that equates any disturbance with disaster and the romantic faith that breaking the order is automatically a step toward justice.

Write this and mark it free